Streako

Habit swap

Caffeine vs water: swap the extra coffee for a glass of water

Tired at 3pm, so another coffee. But mild dehydration makes you feel tired too, and coffee will not fix that.

The verdict: Keep your morning coffee. Swap the extra ones for water: it fixes the tiredness that comes from not drinking enough, without costing you sleep.

Side by side

Caffeine vs water

Energy
Caffeine: A quick lift, then a dip.
Water: Fixes the fatigue that comes from thirst.
Sleep
Caffeine: Late caffeine can cut sleep by over an hour.
Water: No effect on sleep.
Headaches
Caffeine: Withdrawal headaches if you miss your usual dose.
Water: Mild dehydration headaches go away.
Limit
Caffeine: Up to 400 mg a day for most adults.
Water: Drink to thirst, more when it is hot.
Cost
Caffeine: Coffee shop habits add up.
Water: Almost free.

What it costs

The case against caffeine

Energy drinks add up fast

One 16 oz energy drink can hold anywhere from 54 to 328 mg of caffeine. Two of the strong ones pass the daily limit.

Source: FDA

Lower limits in pregnancy

During pregnancy the advice is no more than 200 mg a day, because high intake is linked to miscarriage and low birth weight.

Source: NHS

What you gain

The case for water

Thirst feels like tiredness

Even mild dehydration lowered mood, increased fatigue and caused headaches in a controlled study, and made tasks feel harder.

Source: J Nutrition, Armstrong et al. 2012

More water, less fatigue

People who normally drank little and raised their intake had significantly less fatigue and confusion within three days.

Source: PLOS ONE, Pross et al. 2014

Your sleep stays intact

Caffeine 6 hours before bed cut sleep by more than an hour without people noticing. Water has no such cost.

Source: AASM

The swap

How to make the swap in Streako

  1. 1

    Add a Yes / No habit called "No caffeine after 2pm", every day, with a reminder at 14:00.

  2. 2

    Add "Drink water" as a Count habit: 8 glasses, every day.

  3. 3

    Before every coffee after your first, drink a full glass of water and wait 10 minutes. Often you will not want the coffee.

  4. 4

    Check in on both each night. Two streaks, one swap: every day you stay clear is also a day you did something better.

FAQ

Caffeine vs water: common questions

Not in the same way. Caffeine is a stimulant; water is not. But if your tiredness comes partly from not drinking enough, water fixes the cause instead of masking it.

Normal amounts of coffee count towards your fluid intake. The problem is coffee replacing water, not coffee draining it.

A short walk. In one study, 10 minutes of walking up stairs made people feel more energetic than a small dose of caffeine.

General information, not medical advice. If you are worried about your health, talk to a doctor.

More habit swaps

Swap one habit this week

Drop one, build one, and check in on both each night.

Share this page

Know someone building a habit?

Habits stick better with company. Send this to a friend, then start a challenge together.

streako.app/swap/caffeine-vs-water

Coming soon on Google Play

Streako is almost here

Be the first to know when it launches. Leave your email and we'll send you one message, with the download link, the day it goes live.

  • One email at launch, nothing else
  • Free to start, no ads on any plan
  • Unsubscribe any time with a reply

We only use your email to tell you about the launch. Privacy policy

What's coming

  • Streaks that forgive
  • XP, levels and 14 badges
  • Challenges with friends
  • Reminders that fit your day
  • Stats that show progress